First thanks to Doug for this great post!
I'm not a fan of knurled nuts/screws at all.
Like you I prefer something else, there are actually lots of ideas here each with its disadvantages and advantages.
For industry work we often use "Shear Lok" press on knobs. Of course this means buying the press on knobs.
When I need to make a knob I do prefer a flutted design myself or maybe better described as lobes. The big problem here is the sharp edges which have to be blended in. Add a few holes around the perimeter of Tommy bars when you over tighten things and need little extra leverage to unscrew.
Sometime the big knob doesn't work well so a stud with Tommy bar can be a good choice. I call this the C-Clamp look.
I like fairly heavy blending and often use course Scotch Brite wheels on a right angle die grinder.
One solution is to run a file over the knurls after they've been formed. This will knock the tops off the little pyramids that form the knurl and make it more comfortable to handle.
Sometimes when crude will do welding a bar across the top of a cap screw can produce a rugged and quick solution.For beefier stuff I prefer fluting. It provides a firm grip and is much easier on the hands. An example is my tripod quick release handle...
http://www.homemadetools.net/forum/t...-release-27215
In any event I'm liking all these ideas. This has been a great thread already.
Bookmarks