I bought a top and bottom cabinet of the 54" Carlyle tool cabinet from my local NAPA dealer in Canada. When researching the cabinet, I had a heck of a time finding much information on these cabinets - not a lot of reviews or feedback as to quality. I had checked out the big box offerings and was quite unimpressed - I didn't want an 18" deep cabinet, I didn't want flimsy sheet metal, and I wanted some ball bearing drawers that I felt reasonably confident in. Combine that with a preference for many small drawers over few large ones, and I stumbled across the Carlyle.

Pretty happy overall. If you want to take a look there is a video I made below, as I came across the question about Carlyle quality far more often than I came across people that had actually put their hands on one. Ultimately I wanted to try to remedy that a little bit and make sure there was a little more user experience and feedback available.